The “GOAT” or “greatest of all time” in men’s tennis has remained a topic of frequent debate since 2011. However, the argument has always come down to two key players: Federer and Djokovic. Statistically speaking, Djokovic indisputably wins the debate. With a record total of 24 grand slam titles, as well as being the only man in tennis history to achieve a triple Career Grand Slam by winning each of the four major tournaments at least three times, Djokovic’s success on paper is particularly excellent compared to Federer’s. Along with the major Grand Slams, Djokovic has had staggering success with the ATP Masters tournaments, winning an all-time record of 40 Masters titles and being the only player to win six Masters titles in one season. 

But statistics aren’t everything. One could also rate the “greatest of all time” by artistic play, or style. In this category, the winner is hands-down Federer. No one has ever played the game as beautifully, aggressively, or as perfectly as him. During his peak between the years of 2004-2007, Federer redefined what dominance meant in the sport of tennis. With his vast shot-selection ability, incredible precision, and graceful footwork, Federer has always possessed an unparalleled ease on the court, unable to be surpassed or matched by any other player. Djokovic himself, Federer’s chief rival, has recognized this, saying, “His impact on the game has been tremendous, the way he was playing, his style, effortless, just perfect for an eye of a tennis coach, player or just a tennis fan.” 

So, while the winner is still unclear, I personally feel that Federer will always be the GOAT. Federer dominated during the “Golden Age,” competing amongst the likes of Andre Agassi, Pete Sampras, and Andy Roddick. At his peak, Federer was a more masterful player than Djokovic, with a wide variety of tools in his arsenal – including his acclaimed one-handed backhand, perfect forehand, and incredible backhand smash. Federer’s career invoked a sense of pure awe across the tennis community, for players and fans alike. His dominance was beautiful, and is the reason why Federer is undoubtedly the greatest of all time.